teubbist

Ars Scholae Palatinae
823
They also released their offset mounting kit for AM5(mainly, but works with AM4), Noctua post/press release about it.

I find it curious they mentioned der8auer's collaboration on the direct die kit development, but not for the offset mount kit. der8auer was, AFAIK, the first to release an offset mounting kit for AM4 but maybe Noctua created their version entirely internally.
 
  • Like
Reactions: continuum

continuum

Ars Legatus Legionis
94,897
Moderator
I'm still holding off on upgrading, but definitely exciting to see further developments in Zen 4 cooling.


Scythe Fuma 3 released. Dual 120mm fan tower with 6 x 6mm heat pipes so not the craziest, but looks like the rear fin stack is pretty good sized, so am curious how it performs.
 

mokodi

Ars Scholae Palatinae
684
I'm still holding off on upgrading, but definitely exciting to see further developments in Zen 4 cooling.


Scythe Fuma 3 released. Dual 120mm fan tower with 6 x 6mm heat pipes so not the craziest, but looks like the rear fin stack is pretty good sized, so am curious how it performs.
Looks like it’s up on Newegg for $50. It has steep competition from Thermalright. I do like Scythe products though, my Mugen 2 from 2009 is still going strong!
 

continuum

Ars Legatus Legionis
94,897
Moderator

Thermalright Assassin X 120 Plus V2, dual 120mm fan single tower cooler, 4x 6mm heat pipes. No TDP on their website but guessing aimed at the mid-range rather than the top of the market.
 

continuum

Ars Legatus Legionis
94,897
Moderator

Scythe Fuma 3 review at Tom's Hardware. For $45 looks quite decent. Ryzen 7700X testing includes Thermalright Peerless Assassin where it looks like it trades blows, on the i7-13700K it looks substantially better.
 

continuum

Ars Legatus Legionis
94,897
Moderator

be quiet! Dark Rock Pro 5.... light on details tho...


Arctic P8 Max PWM fan. Given how few 80mm fan releases there are (admittedly because there isn't much need for them in enthusiast space), seems worth nothing. Note that the increased efficiency claims are for power consumption reduction rather than noise or airflow.
 

continuum

Ars Legatus Legionis
94,897
Moderator

Finally a non-video Thermalright Frost Commander 140 review. Looks good on both Intel and AMD testbeds, even more so if you consider the very affordable price. That said if ultimate performance but also noise levels are a consideration, then a different unit might be better.
 

continuum

Ars Legatus Legionis
94,897
Moderator
Same same. It's so affordable.

Also:
Watercool your PS5 courtesy of EK (!).

Watercool Heatkiller V Pro RTX 4090 for Asus TUF and STRIX cards review... looks good but Alphacool's block looks better.
 

continuum

Ars Legatus Legionis
94,897
Moderator

Noctua NH-U14S TR5-SP6 and NH-D9 TR5-SP6 4U heatsink/fan for AMD's new Zen 4 based Threadripper and Threadripper Pro (TR5 (sTR5/sTRX5/sWRX9) and SP6 socket).

Also NM-TR5-SP6 mounting kit for existing TR4-SP3, DX-4677, DX-4189 and DX-3647 coolers to be reused.



Arctic Freezer 4U-M Cooler for new Threadripper as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Nevarre

continuum

Ars Legatus Legionis
94,897
Moderator
Noctua NF-A12x25 PWM production differences at Igor's Lab. Looks like the new one, if slightly behind in airflow in free air, is slightly ahead in noise and static pressure against radiator-- in some cases it's ahead by 3dbA or more which is pretty good, although the average difference is generally smaller than 3dBA.

The performance has changed significantly. The significantly lower operating noise is completely acceptable, and the curves also look better. The new fan performs a bit worse at around 1000 rpm in terms of volume flow, but generally offers more pressure and also a lower noise emission in relation to the throughput.

Lian-li GA II LCD 360 and its GA II Trinity Performance have been reviewed a bunch, here's one more review.

beQuiet Dark Rock Elite at Igor's Lab.

Sadly they don't actually include testing charts. I thought they did have a testing database accessible somewhere but I'm not seeing it at the moment. I do appreciate that Igor's Lab uses a Zen 2 CPU with two chiplets as that's much more relevant to my personal boxes these days than testbeds with Intel monolithic dies; finding reviewers (at least as I write this post) using Intel CPUs is (relatively speaking) currently pretty easy.
 

continuum

Ars Legatus Legionis
94,897
Moderator

For 2U chassis with upcoming Intel Granite Rapids, aka Intel Xeon Scalable 6th gen, on LGA 7529.

Intel's LGA7529 CPUs aimed at 2U and larger servers. The device has a water block with a water pump that flows liquid at 1.7 liters a minute and a radiator equipped with three high-pressure 80-mm fans. These fans spin at up to 8000 revolutions per minute to produce an airflow of over 115 CFM while generating noise level of around 57 dBA. The cooling system is rated for up to 700W.
 

Rastaman

Ars Tribunus Militum
2,033
Surprised no one's yet mentioned the Alphacool Apex Stealth Metal (Power) Fan. Review went up on Igor's Lab two weeks ago. At the moment, they only come in 120mm, but according to the datasheet 140mm, and ARGB versions are coming. Testing provided very impressive results. Looking forward to more sites getting their hands on them for review and seeing what the 140 version can accomplish.
 
Last edited:

Rastaman

Ars Tribunus Militum
2,033
Woah, that looks amazing. First actual big step in fan performance (vs incremental) in a while, although honestly the past 3 years or so we've seen some solid incremental gains too.

I browse Igors Lab semi-regularly, clearly not enough!
Fair play to Alphacool. They are probably one of the few companies in the industry with the clout and scale to attempt something like this. Be interesting to see how Noctua respond!
To be fair, this is the "Power" version running at 40dBm, and not the silent version. But, it did a decent job against all fans, including the Cooler Master Mobius which comes in at 30dB, at the same RPM.

Still, I'd place it on a 240 radiator myself, if I really needed it and wanted to spend $60 on two fans...
 
Last edited:

steelghost

Ars Praefectus
4,975
Subscriptor++
The thing that struck me was the comparison between the Apex Stealth and eith the CM or Noctua fan - at any RPM, the AC fan was quieter by 5-6dBA than the competition. Or if you noise normalised, you get a lot more static pressure or free air flow out of the AC fan. Any way you look at it, it's just handing them their arses in a sling :LOL:

Definitely not something to put in push-pull on a big heatsink though, that would really be scary for the socket mounting etc. If they can be said to have a weakness, it's the weight, and of course, the price.
 
  • Like
Reactions: continuum

continuum

Ars Legatus Legionis
94,897
Moderator
As reminded by willdude, the Thermalright Phantom Spirit 120 might be the current budget heatsink to beat, or at least up among the very top given the current price of under $37 shipped.

 
  • Like
Reactions: malor

wireframed

Ars Legatus Legionis
16,733
Subscriptor
Surprised no one's yet mentioned the Alphacool Apex Stealth Metal (Power) Fan. Review went up on Igor's Lab two weeks ago. At the moment, they only come in 120mm, but according to the datasheet 140mm, and ARGB versions are coming. Testing provided very impressive results. Looking forward to more sites getting their hands on them for review and seeing what the 140 version can accomplish.
Pretty amazing performance, especially regarding static pressure. It doesn’t look like an 80mm version is coming? Shame, my server case could use a couple of those.
 

Rastaman

Ars Tribunus Militum
2,033
I held off mentioning it here, but the Alphacool fans have quite a big question mark with the r/hardware community wrt the ratings (which looked like igor was copying alphacool's data or vice versa). Derbauer got his hands on the fans and the results are way off.


View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8J7jkRbxLYk

Yeah, der8auer's testing at most somewhat supported the noise level results, with the massive caveat that his noise floor isn't very low. Everything else failed to come even close to igor's results.

Now we wait for more testing I guess, but Noctua not being dethroned is both unsurprising and a little sad.
Shame if so. There are a lot of applications for quiet(er) fans with high static pressure. :(
Oh well, the server can keep the Noctua 80mms for now. :)

Well, it looks like the chatter was valid. Igor's Lab released a statement indicating there were errors in the testing and amended the original October 2023 article. I fully respect this move on the part of transparency and appreciate the fact that the site is going to keep the corrected post up for the foreseeable future to demonstrate they're owning up to the mistake.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: continuum

teubbist

Ars Scholae Palatinae
823
I don't think they had much choice, too much evidence was emerging that the original testing was complete bunk. And people were getting pretty rowdy in forums and reddit over the matter, not helped by some of Pascal's(original tester) responses.

der8auer did a fairly extensive video in German as a followup. The English version is AI translated which got most of the substance across, albeit with some odd formal language in places and excursions into a British accent.


View: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cHNXFgSonWI
 

continuum

Ars Legatus Legionis
94,897
Moderator

As usual take all claims with some skepticism until 3rd party test results are available.

The V8 3DVC is a completely new cooler from Cooler Master that is capable of handling CPU thermal loads of up to 300W. The vapor chamber has been completely redesigned to improve thermal efficiency. The heat pipes used in the V8 3DVC are Cooler Master's latest Superconductive Composite heat pipe technology, which reportedly doubles the "q-max" or the maximum heat transfer efficiency of the heat pipes.

and:
Like its air-cooled counterpart, the G11 is an entirely new AIO cooler from Cooler Master, capable of dissipating CPU thermal loads beyond 300W. The heart of the new cooler is an all-new dual pump, a dual chamber design that reportedly increases pressure and heat dissipation efficiency.
 

continuum

Ars Legatus Legionis
94,897
Moderator

Thermal Grizzly Kryosheet tests on an up to 475W AMD Radeon 7900XTX. It's pretty interesting.
 

malor

Ars Legatus Legionis
16,093

Thermal Grizzly Kryosheet tests on an up to 475W AMD Radeon 7900XTX. It's pretty interesting.
I'm not touching the Kryonaut goop I've got going now, since it's working super well, but those Kryosheets are high on the list for my next build.

You can't screw up the application, it never wears out, and it handles huge amounts of heat. That's, like, the best solution ever. It's almost as thermally conductive as metal paste, with none of the drawbacks.
 
I'm not touching the Kryonaut goop I've got going now, since it's working super well, but those Kryosheets are high on the list for my next build.

You can't screw up the application, it never wears out, and it handles huge amounts of heat. That's, like, the best solution ever. It's almost as thermally conductive as metal paste, with none of the drawbacks.
For me, I'm seeing a glass half empty, as it seems like it could be better for very high power loads and it shouldn't try out (I would like to see an extended test), otherwise I didn't see a major difference with their graphs, even their own conclusion wasn't impressing me:
Looking at GPU temperature I'd say that all materials tested, including KryoSheet perform virtually identically. A difference of 1-3°C really doesn't matter much, unless you're trying to break records. Even for overclocking I wouldn't bet my system stability on a 3°C difference, because that might disappear in summer months, when your AC is off, or when a long gaming session heats up your room. While the temperature results for "hotspot" are similar, they do show a little bit of a bigger spread, up to 5°C, which is starting to become significant, at least for a high-end graphics card. For lower-end cards that run pretty cool anyway, there is no functional difference between 75°C and 80°C, for example, other than the number in monitoring software. Silicon lifetime isn't affected enough by such a small difference, and I think statistically the chances of you breaking the product while applying thermal paste are higher than just letting it run untouched. On the other hand, as mentioned before, after many years, thermal pastes have a tendency to dry out, so replacing thermal paste once during the lifetime of the product does make sense. Using KryoSheet could save you that step, because it won't degrade over time.
temp-gpu.png

temp-hotspot.png

Honestly, this reminds me of audiophile gear, where if you don't measure the component signals with a spectrum analyzier, you're ears will never notice the difference, but it's costs more, so it has to better, even if it falls with the uncertainty of measurement. If TG can make this closer to price of paste, sure, why not, but at 2-3x the cost?
 

malor

Ars Legatus Legionis
16,093
If TG can make this closer to price of paste, sure, why not, but at 2-3x the cost?
I've dealt with enough bad paste applications, over the years, that a simple thermal sheet is super appealing. As long as you keep it flat and centered on the die, it'll work correctly every time, and it will keep working, no matter what.

That's miles better than paste. And you're not trading anything away except an extra $10 or $15. It works just as well as paste does, with none of the disadvantages.

It has nothing to do with audiophilia. The graphs you show are very powerful evidence in favor; they're concrete measurements that they do a very good job of transmitting heat. They're showing that you don't need paste anymore. Earlier dry thermal pads worked to some degree, but were inferior to even crummy paste, but this variant is just as good.

The fact that the differences aren't that major is the entire point of those graphs. Them being all jammed together like that means that the product works correctly. You can safely use Kryosheets without giving up performance.
 

cerberusTI

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
6,449
Subscriptor++
I've dealt with enough bad paste applications, over the years, that a simple thermal sheet is super appealing. As long as you keep it flat and centered on the die, it'll work correctly every time, and it will keep working, no matter what.

That's miles better than paste. And you're not trading anything away except an extra $10 or $15. It works just as well as paste does, with none of the disadvantages.

It has nothing to do with audiophilia. The graphs you show are very powerful evidence in favor; they're concrete measurements that they do a very good job of transmitting heat. They're showing that you don't need paste anymore. Earlier dry thermal pads worked to some degree, but were inferior to even crummy paste, but this variant is just as good.

The fact that the differences aren't that major is the entire point of those graphs. Them being all jammed together like that means that the product works correctly. You can safely use Kryosheets without giving up performance.
I used one in the last computer I put together and it was fine.

It likes to blow around in any air movement, but that was easily fixed with a very tiny amount of paste in one of the corners, just enough to make it stick as I lowered the heatsink.

Edit:
Anyway, since I finally bothered to finish setting up memory on that one and tested it, the max CPU temperature at any point after a variety of tests including some designed to stress cooling was 72C on a 7800X3D using the Kryosheet and a D-15, which is pretty good. That is not a high power draw chip (especially with PBO off), but it is more than competitive with what I would expect from a good paste.

I will likely use it again in the future.
 
Last edited:

continuum

Ars Legatus Legionis
94,897
Moderator

Corsair Air A115, dual 140mm fan tower. Seems like we are seeing some marginal improvements still in air cooling, at least on the Intel Raptor Lake testbed that Tom's Hardware uses.


And I think people were asking earlier, but Anandtech has finally reviewed the be Quiet Dark Rock 5 Pro as well.
 

Baenwort

Ars Tribunus Militum
2,470
Subscriptor++
I've dealt with enough bad paste applications, over the years, that a simple thermal sheet is super appealing. As long as you keep it flat and centered on the die, it'll work correctly every time, and it will keep working, no matter what.

That's miles better than paste. And you're not trading anything away except an extra $10 or $15. It works just as well as paste does, with none of the disadvantages.

It has nothing to do with audiophilia. The graphs you show are very powerful evidence in favor; they're concrete measurements that they do a very good job of transmitting heat. They're showing that you don't need paste anymore. Earlier dry thermal pads worked to some degree, but were inferior to even crummy paste, but this variant is just as good.

The fact that the differences aren't that major is the entire point of those graphs. Them being all jammed together like that means that the product works correctly. You can safely use Kryosheets without giving up performance.
If I didn't have enough paste to last me the rest of my life time I'd also look into this stuff.

The only use case I'm still buying material are making small self adhesive heatsinks for Pi-like projects or CE items like Rokus that need a little more cooling for confined space mounts. And it doesn't seem that KryoSheet does that (not that those need super performance but I buy a small sheet about once a year and would switch my purchase if it did).

I think I over bought when a couple old webstores like Frozencpu closed shop...

I do think that if either kid gets into it I wont bother teaching them pasting but would go for these pads instead.
 
  • Like
Reactions: malor
This was a few days ago, but Hardware Busters finally got their hands on the Arctic P12 Max and it's performance is really good, especially at the price point:

Power draw is a little on the high side though, which could be easily fixed with powered hubs.
(also supposedly the regular P12s have dropped in price so that's a neat side effect of the new fan release).