Hm. Well, turns out I had another Hatchbox ABS in white, so changed spools. I'll try cutting out a section of the other spool and try it again later.
Also loaded the TPU into the other nozzle, for when I start to print that. Wow, the feel of that stuff is crazy weird! It's 95A, so we'll see if it's tough enough to be a cane foot. I think so, or I'll try combing some ABS/ASA and the TPU on the outside. I suspect I won't, most of the stiffness can be handled by the tube/attachment, while the TPU just needs to be sturdy/wear resistant enough to handle a variety of surfaces. Once I get what I want, I'll just print out a few extra copies to take with me to the festivals just in case.
Maybe if this goes well, my v3 will end up be 3D printed polycarbonate. Need to read up on light channeling/scattering designs though, to give more even glow. That's for the future though. And bonding the pieces together to form the cane tube might be a challenge, to try and get a smooth enough surface with harder to detect/see joints.
EDIT: Still early, but that other roll seems to have done the trick. I think you're right, just a bad section of the ABS.
I think overall, I'm going to be switching to Sunlu/SainSmart/Polymaker for most/all of my filament needs. Although Hatchbox PLA has been really great, but I'm going to be trying out PETG to use instead of PLA for the future, once I get through my existing PLA.