Is a repurposed AMD Ryzen 3600 a reasonable CPU for a home NAS?

Tristram

Ars Scholae Palatinae
1,428
Subscriptor
I have most of a system (sans MB and RAM) if I reuse a recently retired Ryzen 3600 (not k). I was considering just getting a 550M mb with 32gb ECC and create a home nas/media server (trueNas(?)) so about $200 added funds, and the rest off my parts shelf.

I used the 3600 fine for a several years as my main desktop, so it 'feels' plenty fast, but is really? But haven't decided on TrueNAS and I might look at alternatives if OpenZFS is more than the 3600 can handle (OpenMediaVault / RockStor / yada).
 

tiredoldtech

Smack-Fu Master, in training
84
Subscriptor++
Depending on the quality of the board (not all 550M's were built the same), it should be more than enough for a standard home NAS. I made the comment on the 550M as I've seen a few postings where SATA and NVME/M.2 bandwidth was not as hoped for due to design constraints to put in other features on said board vs a competitor's that may not have other features (more 550M standard design). So, unless you're going for insane 10+ simultaneous 4k streaming, large dataset modelling, local hosted gaming- it should be fine.

Also, be aware of a very small number of implementations being affected by a TrueNAS ZFS bug:
https://www.truenas.com/community/t...penzfs-ongoing-discussion-and-testing.114390/

All of that being said, the rig as described should be good for several more years of use as a NAS, provided you have the proper power supply for said board/processor, drives. You made no comment on video card, so that also would come into consideration if you were expecting your NAS to do transcoding for video streaming (not so much drive bandwidth, but power consumption and power supply requirements).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tristram

Tristram

Ars Scholae Palatinae
1,428
Subscriptor
Cool.

Got a ASRock 550m Steel Legend and 32gb ecc for $215. Using sons retired GeForce 1050ti (which seems overkill for nas, but it was surplus). Using ASUS nvme card (long story, but was surplus because i didn't pay attention to pcie channel reqts a few years ago) that holds 4 ssd and an old haf case with a Corsair 550 power supply. After it is set up, it will be headless in mechanical room.

Thanks for the help.
 
  • Like
Reactions: r0twhylr

tiredoldtech

Smack-Fu Master, in training
84
Subscriptor++
Depending on which calculator you use to find the specific PSU minimum for your rig, it appears 550w should be more than enough under load (by about 50w-100w) and should handle things well. As for using that video card in your rig- yes, it's overkill for NAS, but if you run any video streaming from it (such as using Plex, JellyFin, etc), it will happily allow you to run 3 transcode 4k streams (and it supports HEVC too) at the same time without issue. It sounds as described (without more specifics) as a solid and fast hardware build that should work well for many years. (y)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tristram

r0twhylr

Ars Tribunus Militum
2,131
Subscriptor++
I realize I'm coming to the party a little late here, but FWIW I have a pair of older FreeNAS builds and a newer TrueNAS build all running on 1ghz dual core AMD Turion procs. They aren't particularly robust, but they're fine for storing home pictures, a movie repository, my ISO library, backups, etc. Your CPU will be fine. Cheers, and good luck!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Tristram

Tristram

Ars Scholae Palatinae
1,428
Subscriptor
Yes, it is quit fast. I built it using the the ASRock 550m Steel Legend and 32 GB ECC and ... UnRaid. I didn't take into account the lack of graphical desktop, and how much RAM and CPU would be freed up.

I got UnRaid just before they announced the licensing change. I chose UnRaid because it's disk management reminded me strongly of Windows Home Server v1 (I ran one for about 10 years before retiring it), and I have a ... variety of disks lying around.

I have 2x4TB and 2x3TB red NAS drives. 2x2TB desktop drives, and a 3x2TB,1x500GB NVMe drives. It is very satisfying so far!