Replacement for ASUS RT-N66U router

Xelas

Ars Praefectus
5,444
Subscriptor++
TP-Link makes some nice devices too.

APs today are not like the bad old days of the WRT54GL or your Asus RT routers where you had to flash 3rd party firmware to have a router that isn't total gobshite.
For the first year or two, yes. The real proof, though, is for how long the manufacturer supplies firmware updates for security. Sometimes the only way to continue to securely use a device that has been abandoned is to install 3rd party firmware.
When I last used a consumer router (~10 years ago), Asus was good with long-term support, TP-Link, not so much.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zakman

Ardax

Ars Legatus Legionis
19,076
Subscriptor
The real proof, though, is for how long the manufacturer supplies firmware updates for security.
That's fair -- I didn't think of that. (Yay for country living where I don't have any drive-by hacking or wireless interference)

Did anyone ever solve the need for binary blobs for full performance with 3rd party firmware? I remember looking into using OpenWRT on my old TP-Link router and finding out that the router's performance was a lot lower because certain binary blobs weren't being loaded.

That might be another area where Asus wins, if they're still working more closely with 3rd party firmware authors.

I was on an upgrade treadmill replacing routers every few years anyway to support newer standards as the rest of the hardware in my house improved.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zakman

Xelas

Ars Praefectus
5,444
Subscriptor++
That's fair -- I didn't think of that. (Yay for country living where I don't have any drive-by hacking or wireless interference)
Regardless of whether you live in the country or in downtown NYC, you are connected to the same internet and vulnerable routers get hacked from the internet (WAN) side all the time.
 

Lord Evermore

Ars Scholae Palatinae
1,490
Subscriptor++
Did anyone ever solve the need for binary blobs for full performance with 3rd party firmware? I remember looking into using OpenWRT on my old TP-Link router and finding out that the router's performance was a lot lower because certain binary blobs weren't being loaded.
That depends on the chipsets used in the device, mainly Broadcom. Broadcom doesn't produce fully open source drivers, and OpenWrt won't use proprietary ones. Some chipsets are supported, but they aren't usually using drivers from Broadcom, so it often doesn't work completely. The RT-N66U only has partial 2.4GHz support (no N capability) and doesn't support 5GHz at all. (Two different controllers for the two bands is common.) OpenWrt also can't see the full RAM capacity. DD-WRT is willing to use proprietary driver blobs, so it's able to provide full functionality of the hardware.

 
  • Like
Reactions: zakman

continuum

Ars Legatus Legionis
94,897
Moderator

I've been looking at the Asus GT-AX6000 as it gets good feedback on SmallNetBuilder, but honestly. I'm trying to hold off for more WiFi 7 choices.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zakman

Paladin

Ars Legatus Legionis
32,552
Subscriptor

I've been looking at the Asus GT-AX6000 as it gets good feedback on SmallNetBuilder, but honestly. I'm trying to hold off for more WiFi 7 choices.
Yeah, that is why I ended up getting a $55 refurb option when my old TP-Link router finally needed replacing (after like 8 years of use or something). WiFi 7 will be nice once it is in everything on the market. Until then, it's not super interesting to me at home.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zakman

Paladin

Ars Legatus Legionis
32,552
Subscriptor
WiFi 7 seems like a legit upgrade, with measured speeds of 2+ Gbps, seemingly bottlenecked by the 2.5 Gbps Ethernet port on the Unifi 7 Pro. Multiple bands connected at once also means no more interruptions by moving slightly out of 5/6 Ghz range and needing to reconnect to 2.4.
Oh yeah, I don't debate the theoretical benefits, especially in a dense setup but for my needs at home (a small handful of mobile devices doing basic gmail, streaming, facebook, etc. and a couple of wifi cameras) it is pretty pointless to spend money on.
 

w00key

Ars Praefectus
5,907
Subscriptor
Oh yeah, I don't debate the theoretical benefits, especially in a dense setup but for my needs at home (a small handful of mobile devices doing basic gmail, streaming, facebook, etc. and a couple of wifi cameras) it is pretty pointless to spend money on.
For me it's mostly to get rid of the last bit of range issues. It annoys me that sometimes it takes a while before my phone switches to 2.4 Ghz when signal drops to unusable. Throughput is nice but not a must have, although faster than wired in real life, not just on the spec sheet is pretty crazy.

That was even without MLO, bundling all 3 bands is going to make wireless finally as good as, or better than a RJ45 port unless you go 2.5/10G.



But for now yeah just go with whatever. 6 is nice, as it finally upgrades 2.4 from N (AC is 5Ghz only), but not a must have. I'm waiting for 7 to finalize (nope to "draft" gear), then drop in price, not going to get a €800 pair of TP Link Decos for WiFi 7.
 

Ardax

Ars Legatus Legionis
19,076
Subscriptor
Multiple bands connected at once also means no more interruptions by moving slightly out of 5/6 Ghz range and needing to reconnect to 2.4.
Oh that sounds amazing. It's also nigh useless until I get a new phone that's WiFi 7, because most of my wireless devices don't really move much. Many of them need hardwired, but that requires buying cables, which will mean pulling cables. Eventually sure, but not right now.
 
  • Like
Reactions: zakman

Paladin

Ars Legatus Legionis
32,552
Subscriptor
I haven't had any issues with Amazon or Ebay in ordering this kind of thing. Amazon generally has a great return policy and you can easily tell which things are sold by Amazon or marketplace sellers. Ebay has decent policies as well. If you're not comfortable with those, B&H is probably fine, Newegg is probably less reliable than Amazon. You could look for a local store like BestBuy but they typically have very poor stock for anything outside of a a very small handful of models. Microcenter might be ok if you have one nearby.
 

Kyuu

Ars Tribunus Militum
2,441
Subscriptor
As a counterpoint to Paladin, I avoid Amazon for purchases as much as possible. Not just because they are unreliable, but also filled with garbage and just generally an all-around terrible company. Alternates to try:

B&H
Best Buy (they have online stock as well, you're not just limited to what's carried in the physical stores)
Adorama
Dell (yes they sell a lot of electronics besides their own stuff)
Lenovo (similar to Dell)
Newegg (reliable in my experience as long as you stick with the what's stocked and shipped by Newegg, not the stuff sold by third-party stores)
Office Depot
 

Paladin

Ars Legatus Legionis
32,552
Subscriptor
Yeah, I generally have a growing aversion to Amazon on a kind of moral/bsuiness ethics level but there are times when I can't find what I want from anywhere else, or at least not easily or within a reasonable price difference. I always check ebay and a couple of other sources first these days. Heck, I've ordered from Temu and Aliexpress for a few handfuls of stickers and other things my wife uses for student prizes in her classes because they are the same thing you get on Amazon but for half the price or less. Talk about the lesser of two weavils though... ;)
 

804solutions

Smack-Fu Master, in training
74
My RT-N66U home router is starting to show its age, and I'd prefer upgrading the router rather than flashing firmware to one of the open-source firmwares.

Don't really need anything too fancy, it's just me and a couple of devices on the network. Just something a bit more modern.

Any suggestions, or more info required?
Wow that was a great router 10+ years ago. Ahead of its time. You could buy almost anything now and see a big improvement assuming you have modern devices. I'd recommend TP-Link or Asus.