Advice on device for Sketchbook app - tablet/PC touchscreen?

My wife uses the Sketchbook app for cartooning for her website (linkage). Past history is using the original Kindle Fire HDX 8.9 with a stylus. She also was using a much older version of Android Sketchbook since the Kindle OS wasn't updated for the more current Sketchbook. Sometime roughly a year ago the stuff hit the fan with being able to download her work from the old Kindle to her Win 10 Dell laptop (which is old enough that it doesn't pass the Win 11 check) and she started using my 2022 iPad Air with 2nd gen Apple pencil and the current iOS Sketchbook and transferring files via iCloud. That got her through the short-term work phase (she has cartoons prepared out a long way and pre-loaded for posting).

She's not real keen on getting an iPad for herself (and I'd just as soon not give up mine for her work time each day :cool:) for the expense and limited use otherwise. Given that her laptop will start aging out of support next year, she's open to a new computer (otherwise, not - she's fine with what it does for what she needs - basic browsing and email) if she could also use it for drawing and then posting to her blog.

What to look at? My limited searching this morning seems to suggest a Surface machine of some type, but there also seem to be enough problems with them that make it a bit sketchy in a bad way.

So if we don't go Apple, we'd need Windows 11, touchscreen, pen compatibility (she does not want to work with something like a Wacom - she wants to draw directly on the screen), etc. Thinness and ability to use like a tablet when sketching would be almost a requirement.

Suggestions? Thanks.
 

Andrewcw

Ars Legatus Legionis
18,129
Subscriptor
Surface Pro. N-Trig. Yeah there are long term quality issues but when you pack a full machine into a tablet screen. Things are bound to break over the years because of heat. Also was her Dell a N-Trig screen. Eg did her stylus need a AAAA battery to work?

Then the other question is does she need it to be on the device itself. Or can you use a separate monitor that does pen input. Because that opens up the door to a lot of things.

I mean she probably wants is Wacom. A Wacom Cintiq. I remember when those were $5K a piece and i bought a Thinkpad X60 Tablet to get the Poor Man's Cintiq for $2500. Now they're down to $800 entry level as the competition starts at $300.
 
Her Dell is a Latitude 3570 from late 2016; no touchscreen. She's never used it for her cartooning - just the Fire HDX and lately my iPad Air. The stylus for the Kindle was just a finger replacement thing - passive, totally (link).

She wants to draw directly on whatever screen - not on a separate pad. She doesn't want the hand-eye thing to be separated.

The Wacom Cintiq would probably work, but anything beyond the budget for another iPad Air probably is a non-starter.
 

Andrewcw

Ars Legatus Legionis
18,129
Subscriptor
Yeah so she's used to using a dull crayon to make drawings. I dunno what to say.

I'd say bite the bullet and buy the minimal Apple iPad that supports Pencil 2. But if you insist on buying the cheapest new iPad available then use the Logitech Crayon over Pencil 1. You lose pressure sensitivity but she never had it before. And do not buy Pencil 1.

Unless she never wants to learn there are far better tools then. In which that case is see if sketchbook works on the Amazon Fire 10 tablet.

Samsung tablets are way way way more stupidly expensive. And you're somewhat not keen on a 2nd screen tethered to a laptop as they cost almost as much as a lowend iPad without the portability or functionality sans laptop.
 

steelghost

Ars Praefectus
4,975
Subscriptor++
I'd say bite the bullet and buy the minimal Apple iPad that supports Pencil 2
++

In the case that your wife doesn't like drawing on a separate device, this really is going to be the next best thing. Plus

Thinness and ability to use like a tablet when sketching would be almost a requirement.
I mean, you have that right there. For browsing etc you can also connect an iPad to a monitor via HDMI and use a bluetooth mouse and keyboard, so it can probably do most of the things a laptop would need to do perfectly well, while being better suited to the primary use case.
 
Thanks for all the input; we'll probably end up with her using my iPad Air then, with pencil2. Very doubtful she'll want to spring for another tablet just for her drawing. I had hopes to upgrade her laptop with something she could also draw with... She'll use a laptop for regular computer stuff, and then be glad she doesn't have to fool with iCloud, etc., to get her drawings where she can put them on Word Press.

I've been a bit amazed at what she's been able to do art-wise with just that basic stylus, zooming in to do details, and many, many layers to control what shows in the final image.
 
Does it HAVE to be a new iPad? Plenty of older used iPads available very cheaply.

My family member is a semi-pro artist and happily uses a 2018 iPad Pro 12.9“. That’s an absolutely top-end artist device. I haven’t checked prices recently but I think they go for about $300-$350 used.

If you want to go cheaper, get the smaller Pro version or the non-Pro version or an older version. You’ll want to buy something that comes bundled with the pen which will be a bit extra.

FYI my family has various iPads and the oldest one is an iPad Air 2013 which STILL gets almost daily use for watching Netflix, Apple TV and YouTube. (The iPad mini and various Kindle Fire tablets have all been a waste of money though. )
 
  • Like
Reactions: steelghost
her Win 10 Dell laptop (which is old enough that it doesn't pass the Win 11 check)
Kinda off-topic, but this can be worked around if she's happy with the laptop.

edit:
wrt Surface products: I've bought a few, both surface pros and surface laptops. I've also found them to be somewhat failure prone. That's why I've bought a few. 🙁

However, I keep going back to them for the screen: resolution and aspect ratio. Since the screen is one of my main interfaces with the computer, that has become a critical criterion for me. They're not cheap, though.
 
Last edited: